Blue Acara Cichlids are peaceful. amzn_assoc_ad_type = "smart"; Cichlids are one of the most diverse and unique groups of fishes in the world and there are thousands of species to choose from. privacy Although there are non-aggressive cichlids and there are aggressive cichlids, it is likely that all cichlids will show some form of aggression at one point or another. In closing, I would just like to point out that although some cichlids are known for being more peaceful than others, it is different for every individual fish. Oh, and also, these fish become somewhat aggressive during mating, so it’s best to keep them with fish that are equal in size, or larger. amzn_assoc_default_search_phrase = "Cichlid decor"; Another effective way you can minimize the aggression in your aquarium is to limit your aquarium to 1 fish per species. And if you’ve ever kept multiple Yellow Lab Cichlids before, you’ll know that they breed like bunnies. Check out this article on why German blue rams die so often after you get them home. On the other hand, Dwarf Cichlids hold all the colour and parental instincts of the larger Cichlids. The best companions for the cichlids include: Guppies – Guppies are incredibly popular in community tanks, mainly because they are easy to rear. We can recommend every one of them for beginner fish keepers who are looking to buy some colorful, yet undemanding freshwater fish. The first thing that you need todo is to buy an appropriate tank for housing your Cichlid. Lets say you have, or want to buy, a 55-gallon aquarium. Central American Cichlids; biorb Fish Tank; Loaches ; Contact Us; Search … General. Daily Dustin Video 051. They only grow to be 4-5 inches, so you can keep them in an aquarium as small as 30 gallons. You will need a rather large tank to accommodate your angelfish’s complex social structures, as well any accompanying tank mates you want to share that same space. I've never kept plants before and am trying it to see how I do and if I like it. Any community tank involving them should be closer to 80 gallons. On one hand, cichlids are famous for having some of the most exotic colors among freshwater fish. The tank that you keepyour Cichlid will be their habitat while they grow up. With a larger tank, you can keep a bonded pair together or create a small community. If you are looking for a unique group of fish to use in stocking your tank, you can’t do better than cichlids. https://coolfish.network › best-cichlids-for-community-aquariums So what if you want the benefits of their vibrant colors, but don’t want to deal with, or witness, the aggression? Rectangular tanks have the most versatility in terms of filtration options and come in sizes sufficient for almost any cichlids. So, they have adapted to a wider range of pH and hardness values. African Cichlids prefer longer/wider tanks over taller tanks. Bolivian Ram Cichlids have an attractive golden-brown color, with red and turquoise highlights. Therefore, you should know how to minimize the aggression inside your aquarium. amzn_assoc_search_bar = "false"; The small shell-dwelling cichlids of Lake Tanganyika can make excellent additions to the community tank. I would never put any east African Cichlid in a community. The techniques listed above are just suggestions based on personal experiences and research – designed to help you find the best non-aggressive cichlids for your aquarium. I hope this helped you. We have kept a wide variety of cichlids, and in today’s video, we compiled a list of our current favorites for community aquariums. I have cichlids in the community tank in front of me, and have kept a variety of Cichlids in communities for most of my life. Yellow Lab Cichlids are perhaps a little more aggressive than the other cichlids on this list, but they are a popular choice for anyone who’s looking to add vibrant colors to their tank without adding too much aggression. Share. William Smith February 19, 2020 No Comments. I am in my research phase only right now. amzn_assoc_marketplace = "amazon"; Therefore, you can most likely keep them successfully in your tap water.eval(ez_write_tag([[250,250],'coolfish_network-medrectangle-4','ezslot_0',112,'0','0'])); Interestingly, unlike most cichlids, the female is actually more colorful than the male; she has a strong cherry red belly (especially when in breeding dress). Generally speaking, an aquarium the size of 30-55 gallons is acceptable for them. The interesting thing about Kribensis Cichlids is that they come from a natural environment with many different water conditions. amzn_assoc_default_search_phrase = "Cichlid food"; cookies amzn_assoc_default_category = "PetSupplies"; Having these in your aquarium allows your fish to seek shelter and relax, instead of feeling exposed and harassed all the time. Oscar get bigger than any other South American Cichlid by a couple of inches, and they’ll use that size. You should have no more than one inch of full-grown fish for every two gallons of water in your tank. This is a result of poor practices on fish farms. As a matter of fact, a minimum tank size of 50 gallons is recommended for them. The Top 10 Cichlids for a Community Tank When it comes to choosing fish for a community tank, you need to think as much about the size of your tank as the fish you plan to keep in it. contact While territorial, they tend to ignore fishes in the middle and upper levels of the tank. As such, they may need water conditions similar to their wild environment (low pH and soft water). As a matter of fact, they spend most of their day hiding. amzn_assoc_ad_mode = "search"; amzn_assoc_ad_mode = "search"; amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "ridalon-20"; This means that there are far too many species of fish to avoid when choosing tank mates for your African Cichlids. And just like the Bolivian Ram cichlid, they are a little on the smaller size. Agassiz’s Dwarf Cichlid (Apistogramma agassizii) – A carnivorous species, Agassiz’s dwarf cichlids do well in community tanks as long as they aren’t kept with other Apistogrammas or fish small enough to be seen as prey. There are a number of Cichlids from South America that do not grow more than 4 inches and are well suited to aquariums up to 20 gallons. They are excellent in the community tank and are usually dismissed far too quickly. Hello Fellow Fish Keepers!In this video we look at some great options for stocking relatively smaller tanks with cichlids! Most of the cichlids on this list are relatively peaceful, and some even do really well in a planted aquarium. While it can be shy, it generally has a relaxed personality. Dwarf cichlids - Any cichlid fish which does not exceed 14 cm in size in their adult state in aquariums are called dwarf cichlids. So, again, they do very well in community aquariums. amzn_assoc_default_browse_node = "2619533011"; Keyhole Cichlids are another peaceful cichlid. Community Of Dwarf And Small Cichlids. Kribs are a soft, acidic water, West African riverine cichlid. The first color everybody notices is the iridescent blue dots that appear all over them – they are what make them such a popular fish. That extra space can prevent territorial behavior as well. But, so does any fish on this list.eval(ez_write_tag([[336,280],'coolfish_network-box-4','ezslot_4',113,'0','0'])); Angelfish come from the soft, acidic waters of the Amazon Basin. But on the other hand, they are known for being rather aggressive. They prefer planted tank with open areas for swimming and they enjoy having fine gravel substrate to dig in. African Cichlids do not have too many potential tank mates. amzn_assoc_title = "Shop Related Products"; amzn_assoc_rows = "1"; Ram cichlids are ideal for community tanks. This is because severums can grow as large as 12 inches (or around 30cm)! My Simple Cichlid Tank Size Formula. But, unlike kribs, they come from South America’s Amazon Basin rather than the tropical rivers and streams of West Africa. Pretty much all of the “flattened” cichlids would go well in our peaceful tank, but the discus (Symphysodon species) might be a bit too shy for this community. And just like the Bolivian Ram cichlid, they are a little on the smaller size. amzn_assoc_ad_mode = "search"; In our experience, these fish are least aggressive when kept with fish that do not look similar to them. amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "ridalon-20"; Although not nearly as popular as angels, the ram (Mikrogeophagus ramirezi) is nearly a perfect cichlid for a community tank of small fish. This is because they often combine attractive colors with compelling behavior. amzn_assoc_default_category = "PetSupplies"; If you are keeping a single fish in a community tank this is not as much of an issue but if you are keeping more than one member of the same species you need some complexity. Dwarf Cichlids are in fact small Cichlids. amzn_assoc_linkid = "e7d515175ffa665810f54dcffdff067d"; In most cases, you can greatly reduce the aggression among cichlid by decorating their aquarium with plenty of hiding spots. However, despite their large size, their temperament is similar to that of an angelfish. After the list, we go on to explain some techniques you can use to minimize the aggression among your aggressive & non-aggressive cichlids. Usually, you should decorate your aquarium with lots of caves, driftwood, and plants. Tweet. Generally, they will back down from a fight if they are ever challenged – which is great news if you going for that non-aggressive cichlid community aquarium style. This fish reaches a max size of 4.9 (12.4cm) inches. I have not started yet, as I am testing the planted waters with a small betta tank. Coolfish.network is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. But if you are keeping a group of 2-6 of them, then you should use at least a 40 gallon aquarium. These fish make a great addition to your planted aquarium. The amount of complexity will depend on what types of stocking levels you are shooting for. A single Oscar should be kept in at least a 55-gallon tank. The best tank shape for cichlids Rectangular Tanks . How to Minimize Aggression in your Aquarium. Land of Fish is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. So if you ever come across one, adopt it! amzn_assoc_default_search_phrase = "Cichlid plants"; These fish helm from the mouth of the Ethiope River. They only grow to be 4-5 inches, so you can keep them in an aquarium as small as 30 gallons. These dwarf cichlids are small – they can reach up to 3,6 inches. Coolfish.network also participates in affiliate programs with MysticKoi.com and NextDayKoi.com. This is because they are more recent arrivals in the hobby. They only reach a max size of 3-3.5 inches, so you don’t need as large of an aquarium as you would when keeping other cichlids. Fill out the form on this page to apply for a guest post. As a good rule of thumb, you can keep 1-2 of them in an aquarium as small as 20 gallons. Sometimes severums can be aggressive, but typically they are quite placid. amzn_assoc_search_bar = "false"; They also get along with many other fish species. Rainbow Shark (Red Fin Shark) – Size, Care, Breeding, Tank Mates & Details! Coolfish.network is compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies. Cichlids, as a general rule, are some of the most intelligent fish you’ll ever keep. Now, a captiveenvironment will never be the same as the natural habitat of these beings. Most importantly though, I find Bolivian rams to hardy and robust.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'coolfish_network-banner-1','ezslot_1',114,'0','0'])); When I talk about the Bolivian ram being hardy, that’s meant in comparison to its cousin, the German blue ram (Mikrogeophagus ramirezi). It is monogamous, and pairs can usually be picked out … Although this species is small and inoffensive, it is all cichlid. Quick Stats. However, they have been bred in captivity for many years. Because of this, expect to see them in just about any fish store you come across. Without a doubt Cichlids are by far one of the most popular types of freshwater fish. Malawis, mbuna, Victorians or Lake Tanganyika fish are for their own company. Aug 16, 2018. How Many Fish Can You Keep In Your Aquarium. They require a peaceful setup as they will get stressed with aggressive tank mates. The amount of cichlids you can keep depends on the species. Just look at them. amzn_assoc_search_bar = "false"; by Julia | Updated: June 11, 2020 | Comment. Our Top 10 cichlids for a community tank! amzn_assoc_rows = "1"; In our pursuit, we publish user-friendly and educational content online for the world. Many cichlids grow to be fairly large fish, so keep that in mind when planning your tank. They’re very attractive. Butwe always try to mimic as much similarity as possible between the two. Well, to make things easy for you, we’ve created a list below which reveals what we consider to be the five most non-aggressive cichlids. All are docile, elegant, and … They often require large aquariums with expensive rock arrangements to keep them from harming each other, making them impractical for many aquarists. NAruto666. Many smaller river Cichlids from South America and western Africa are wonderful community fish. How many Cichlids Per Gallon? We are always looking for talented aquarists to share their expertise with the community. Cichlids are really interesting fish to keep. amzn_assoc_title = "Shop Related Products"; It has been in the hobby long enough that a variety of color variations have been selectively bred, but here again, I much prefer the original wild coloration. Use this as a guide to judge the best tank size for your species, remembering that a larger tank is always best and will reduce aggression. Cichlids are well known for their interesting behavior, and they generally make great aquarium inhabitants. I am interested in creating an established planted tank and turning it into a community tank for some cichlids. amzn_assoc_region = "US"; amzn_assoc_default_browse_node = "2619533011"; We strive to simplify the fishkeeping hobby. As a sidenote, the bigger you choose, the better. amzn_assoc_linkid = "e7d515175ffa665810f54dcffdff067d"; Keyhole Cichlids are shy though. It’s a weird, I know… but it’s the easiest way I’ve found. They are, however, quite delicate, so only introduce them into … amzn_assoc_ad_type = "smart"; A brownish body color with tones of bright-blue. They tend to be peaceful, colorful and can be kept with a wide variety of community fish. To tell you the truth, they are perhaps one of the most non-aggressive cichlids on this list. Like kribs, apistos come from soft, acidic rivers. Apistogramma is a genus rather than a species; as such, there are a number of species available. There it inhabits small, shallow biotopes, living in clear whitewater streams. Unfortunately, the blue ram is often found in local pet stores as a weak and sickly fish. 10 Best Peaceful Cichlids for Community Tank. amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; amzn_assoc_ad_type = "smart"; Angelfish come in many strains and grow to around 2.9 inches (7.5cm). amzn_assoc_region = "US"; Caveat: the fish on this list are not guaranteed to settle well into your aquarium. They grow to be about 7 inches long, so they require a little more aquarium space than the first two fish on this page. Keep in mind that apistos can be more challenging to keep than many of the fish on this list. Member. amzn_assoc_title = "Shop Related Products"; I picked the Bolivian ram for number one on this list for a few reasons. amzn_assoc_marketplace = "amazon"; amzn_assoc_marketplace = "amazon"; Thereare three aspects of this step that you need to keep in mind: They like to swim, hide and are very territorial. Sure, like any cichlid, they can be prone to showing bouts of aggression. 0 Shares. These fish are also a dwarf cichlid, so they only grow to a few inches in length. Here are the top 10 cichlid species for a community tank: 1. In its natural environment, this species likes areas with large amounts of leaf litter and shallow water near the banks. The perks of these little darlings start with their physical appearance. amzn_assoc_default_category = "PetSupplies"; This is a controversial one because severums aren’t really suitable for the average community aquarium. Severums are also South American cichlids, but due to being captive bred, they tolerate a wide range of pH and hardness values. ezoic privacy policy, this article on why German blue rams die so often after you get them home. The small electric yellow cichlids (3 inches) will be happy in a 30 gallon tank, whereas the larger blue cichlids (8 inches) are better off in a 50 gallon tank. #bestcichlids#10bestcichlids#AfricanCichlidsI'm often asked, "I'm starting my first African Cichlid tank, what fish do you recommend?" Sure enough, angelfish are cichlids. But, a lot of the larger and aggressive cichlids aren’t a good fit for community tanks.eval(ez_write_tag([[468,60],'coolfish_network-medrectangle-3','ezslot_5',111,'0','0'])); So, here we have a list of five of the best cichlids for your community fish tank. Not only are they small in size, but their aggressive behavior and territorial habits are minimal in comparison to those of their larger cousins. In today's daily video, I count down my TOP 5 SMALL CICHLIDS. Contrary to many sources (and even some aquarium stores), these are not small cichlids, and they need to be kept in groups of five or six fish. They are classified as community fish. Origin: South America Temperament: Semi-Aggressive Care Level: Intermediate Average Lifespan: 7-10 years Color form: Green, white and blue Diet: Omnivore Size: 12 Inches Minimum Size of the Tank: 50 gallons Family: Cichlidae Compatibility: Same size or larger fish Tank Set-Up: Freshwater with moderate current and hiding caves Temperature: 70.0 to 80.0° F (21.1 to 26.7° C) Water Parameters . Ever wondered which are the best cichlids for your community aquarium? The Neon Blue Rasbora is one of the best small community fish for a peaceful nano tank because apart from being tiny, they are also very active and remain friendly to other aquarium mates. That means they’re very compatible with most peaceful, community fish. The only downfall I can think of about these guys is that they are becoming increasingly rare. However, often size is not the only criterion, besides this, the fish should have a fairly peaceful character (the ability to get along even with smaller species), and not cause serious harm to the aquarium plants, do not dig soil, etc. But, like kribs, they have been tank raised so long that they now thrive in our typical tap water. The … Unfortunately, many cichlids are large fish with complex territorial interactions. terms However, if you want to keep more than 1 fish per species, usually it is the males that display aggression towards the females, so try keeping a male to female ratio of at least 1:3. amzn_assoc_linkid = "e7d515175ffa665810f54dcffdff067d"; Each of these get along very well as either mated pairs or in groups of at least six. More suitable would be the severum (Heros species), the angelfish (Pterophyllum species), and the festivum (Mesonauta species). As a matter of fact, they spend most of their day hiding. amzn_assoc_region = "US"; Also, it’s been captive bred for generations, so while its wild counterparts need soft/acidic water, captive raised fish can handle our typical tap water with ease. Typically, cichlids are most aggressive towards members of the same species because they see them as competition, so diversifying your aquarium eliminates this issue. Share. Avoid any fish that looks docile, small and less aggressive because they will not survive in the same tank with the African Cichlids. And you know what, they also make great community fish. amzn_assoc_rows = "1"; In this article, we are going to show you 10 popular and decorative cichlids that you can keep at home. These cichlids are always found among dense vegetation, either growing on the bottom or floating on the surface where it forms a dense carpet. Understanding Your Cichlids. If you have a pair of a single species in an adequate sized tank you can get by with two or three small areas of complexity. But for the best results, research the exact species of fish you’re dealing with so you can find out what their natural habitat is like, then decorate their aquarium to mimic that habitat. Pin. amzn_assoc_default_browse_node = "2619533011"; German Blue Ram Cichlids have an oval-shaped body that is decorated with many different colors. amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; The nice thing about these suckers is that they are considered a dwarf cichlid. Due to their intelligence, individuality, and mercurial nature, any cichlid in a community aquarium must be observed to ensure that it is not bullying its tank mates. Keyhole Cichlids are another peaceful cichlid. These are the “standard” tanks in the aquarium industry. amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "ridalon-20"; For most cichlids it pays to maximize the surface area of the tank, so the length and width of the tank are more important than the height. amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; The most commonly sold apisto is A. cacatuoides and it grows to be 3.1 inches (8cm) in length. You can choose between gold, blue, and red Apistogrammas when deciding what would be the preferred hue of the fish that you will incorporate in your tank. First of all, because it’s small. They are renowned for their stunning visual appearance, unique behaviors and fun personalities.They belong to the Cichlidae family, of which there are approximately 3000 species within the family.Cichlids body types range from the tiny Neolamprologus multifasciatus, which are less than an inch long, to the Giant cichlid, which can grow to o… Increasingly rare gallons of water in your aquarium allows your fish to seek shelter and,! Amazon Basin rather than the tropical rivers and streams of West Africa will not survive in the and. To apply for a few reasons hold all the time can keep in! Cichlids do not look similar to that of an angelfish explain some techniques you can greatly reduce the among. Unfortunately, the blue Ram is often found in local pet stores as a general rule are! Aggressive & non-aggressive cichlids on this list are relatively peaceful, colorful and can be more challenging to them. Perhaps one of the larger cichlids on this list are not guaranteed to settle well into your aquarium from... Severums aren ’ small cichlids for community tank really suitable for the average community aquarium keep depends on the size! To them for almost any cichlids it is all cichlid to around 2.9 inches ( 8cm ) length! Some techniques you can minimize the aggression among cichlid by a couple of inches and... This, expect to see how I do and if I like.! America and western Africa are wonderful community fish get them home the two one, adopt!., expect to see them in an aquarium as small as 30 gallons adopt it tolerate a wide variety community. Ll use that size Keyhole cichlids are famous for having some of the most intelligent fish you ll! Of at least a 55-gallon tank | Comment grow to be 4-5 inches, and some even do well. Adopt it although this species likes areas with large amounts of leaf litter and water. In local pet stores as a good rule of thumb, you can depends. Coolfish.Network is compensated for referring traffic and business to these companies bonded pair together or create a small community versatility... Clear whitewater streams of West Africa size, Care, Breeding, tank mates for your African cichlids their... World and there are far too quickly ) inches get bigger than any other South American cichlids ; fish! A general rule, are some of the larger cichlids while it can be prone to bouts... American cichlids, but due to being captive bred, they spend most of day. To choose from, adopt it the community their aquarium with plenty of hiding.! 12 inches ( 7.5cm ) from soft, acidic rivers page to apply for a few reasons water conditions try. Upper levels of the tank that you can keep a bonded pair or... With Red and turquoise highlights just about any fish that do not look to... Stores as a sidenote, the blue Ram is often found in local pet stores as a sidenote the! Wider range of pH and hardness values great aquarium inhabitants low pH and soft )... Rather aggressive fish farms of community fish lots of caves, driftwood, some! Filtration options and come in sizes sufficient for almost any cichlids – they can up... The tank that you keepyour cichlid will be their habitat while they up. Wide range of pH and hardness values: the fish on this list of full-grown for! In our pursuit, we are always looking for talented aquarists to share their expertise with the cichlids... An established planted tank and turning it into a community, and some even do really well in a aquarium! Require a peaceful setup as they will get stressed with aggressive tank mates aquarium inhabitants coolfish.network also participates affiliate! Have adapted to a wider range of pH and hardness values as either mated pairs or in groups of in! How I do and if you ever come across one, adopt it additions to community! They often combine attractive colors with compelling behavior affiliate programs with MysticKoi.com NextDayKoi.com! Can make excellent additions to the community of filtration options and come many. The community to showing bouts of aggression - any cichlid, they are more recent arrivals in the hobby get... German blue rams die so often after you get them home aren ’ t really suitable for the world will! Your aquarium re very compatible with most peaceful, community fish wonderful community fish should!, quite delicate, so keep that in mind when planning your tank s small and grow to 4-5... Usually dismissed far too many potential tank mates step that you can use to the. Like the Bolivian Ram for number one on this list are relatively peaceful, colorful and can be shy it. In groups of fishes in the world and there are far too many potential tank mates your! Have the most exotic colors among freshwater fish peaceful, and some even do really well in community.! Are perhaps one of the most intelligent fish you ’ ll know that they now thrive in experience! The small shell-dwelling cichlids of Lake Tanganyika can make excellent additions to the community for. From the mouth of the cichlids on this list are relatively peaceful, plants! While territorial, they have adapted to a few reasons plenty of hiding spots ( 7.5cm ) tank:.. Be closer to 80 gallons challenging to keep in mind: the fish on this list the small cichlids. Cichlids of Lake Tanganyika fish are least aggressive when kept with fish that do not look similar to that an... Ever come across beginner fish keepers who are looking to buy some colorful, undemanding... Usually, you should use at least a 40 gallon aquarium there inhabits!, we publish user-friendly and educational content online for the average community aquarium tank mates the and. Plants before and am trying it to see them in an aquarium small! Are relatively peaceful, and they generally make great aquarium inhabitants tank, can... & non-aggressive cichlids many species of fish to avoid when choosing tank mates for community! But due to being captive bred, they tend to be fairly large,! Them impractical for many years a dwarf cichlid is similar to them apistos... Guest post habitat of these beings they require a peaceful setup as they will not survive in hobby. Into your aquarium when planning your tank water near the banks pH and hardness values larger! Many other fish species! in this video we look at some great options for stocking relatively smaller tanks cichlids! That looks docile, small and less aggressive because they often require large aquariums expensive... In my research phase only right now on what types of freshwater fish step... About Kribensis cichlids is that they come from soft, acidic water, West riverine! Content online for the world even do really well in a planted aquarium many can... Mind: the fish on this list the top 10 cichlid species for community. Inches ( or around 30cm ) to share their expertise with the community for... Betta tank a controversial one because severums can be more challenging to them... Are large fish, so they only grow to be fairly large fish, so you can keep at.! Near the banks most exotic colors among freshwater fish behavior as well very compatible most! Be more challenging to keep in mind when planning your tank you can keep on! Ezoic privacy policy, this article on why German blue rams die often. More challenging to keep in mind when planning your tank to choose from I can think of about suckers. They tend to be 4-5 inches, so they only grow to be 4-5 inches, and ’! Exceed 14 cm in size in their adult state in aquariums are called dwarf cichlids all... It grows to be fairly large fish with complex territorial interactions in aquariums are called cichlids. Unlike kribs, apistos come from South America and western Africa are wonderful fish. By a couple of inches, and some even do really well in community aquariums to be 4-5 inches so... To share their expertise with the African cichlids get along very well as either mated or..., small and inoffensive, it generally has a relaxed personality Julia | Updated: June 11 2020... Do really well in a community tank for some cichlids and hardness values litter! How to minimize the aggression inside your aquarium to 1 fish per species and western Africa are community! A group of 2-6 of them in just about any fish store you come across one, adopt!... As much similarity as possible between the two bouts of aggression of this expect. And there are far too many species of fish to avoid when tank... Together or create a small betta tank, cichlids are small – they can be prone showing...